Passages

Naboth's Trial: Biblical Law in a Kangaroo Court by Shalom E. Holtz

The biblical story of Naboth's vineyard (1Kgs 21), tells how Ahab, king of Israel, and his wife, Jezebel, arrange for Naboth to be convicted of blasphemy against God and king, in order to take possession of his property.  The trial that Ahab and Jezebel arrange, even though it is a sham, actually obeys proper procedural rules. Jezebel convenes the "elders and nobles" before whom Naboth is to be denounced (1Kgs 21:9-10) and Naboth's accusers testify against him “in the presence of the people" (1Kgs 21:13).

In the book of Deuteronomy, the elders hear accusations prior to a criminal’s execution: the "stubborn and rebellious son" is stoned to death only after his parents appear with him before the elders (Deut 21:18-21; compare the case of the "slandered bride" in Deut 22:13-21). Similarly, in Deuteronomy and elsewhere, the community, not just the elders, is present to validate public hearings, trials, and executions (see Num 35:24, Deut 17:5-7). The presence of the elders and the community ensures that the charge against Naboth—trumped up, of course—will be lodged in a venue with legal standing.

For an accusation to stick, it must not only be made in a proper venue; it must also follow the proper procedure. To this end, Jezebel specifies that there be two witnesses, not just one, to accuse Naboth. This brings the process into line with biblical laws that explicitly prohibit punishment on the basis of just one accuser's word (Num 35:30, Deut 17:6-7). By requiring corroborating testimony, these laws guard against false accusations and a rush to punishment. Thus, Naboth's two false accusers subvert these laws' very purpose!

Apart from these procedural matters, the charge itself, had it been true, would have had the legal outcomes that Jezebel and Ahab imagined. Had Naboth actually "cursed God and the king" (1Kgs 21:10, 1Kgs 21:13), he would have been executed, like the man who blasphemes God in Lev 24:10­-16 and Ahimelech the priest of Nob, whom Saul executes as a traitor for harboring the fugitive David (1Sam 22:9-19). Furthermore, ancient Near Eastern legal records show that the property of those executed for treason was transferred to the king. One legal text from 593 B.C.E. records that the famous Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar II (605–562 B.C.E.) executed a man for treason, took control of his land, and transferred ownership to a temple in the city of Borsippa. According to a provision of the Middle Assyrian Laws (14th century B.C.E.),

If a man, who has not yet received his inheritance share, speaks treason or flees, the disposition of his inheritance share shall be determined by the king.

Like Ahab, the Assyrian king assumes control of the traitor's inheritance property, in place of the traitor and any other heirs. By convicting Naboth in a kangaroo court before his execution, Ahab and Jezebel attempt to launder their corruption in the machinery of justice. Their accusation is rooted in law, but so is the punishment God metes out to them. False accusation, according to the Bible and other ancient legal sources, entailed "do to the false witness just as the false witness had meant to do to the other" (Deut 19:19). Moreover, abuse of royal power, in the Bible and elsewhere, was subject to punishment directly from God, the ultimate judge.

Shalom E. Holtz, "Naboth's Trial", n.p. [cited 25 Apr 2017]. Online: http://bibleodyssey.org/en/passages/related-articles/naboths-trial

Contributors

Shalom E. Holtz

Shalom E. Holtz
Associate Professor, Yeshiva University

Shalom E. Holtz is associate professor of Bible and chair of the Robert M. Beren Department of Jewish Studies at Yeshiva University. He is the author of Neo-Babylonian Court Procedure (Brill, 2009) and Neo Babylonian Trial Records (Society of Biblical Literature, 2014) and coeditor, with Ari Mermelstein, of The Divine Courtroom in Comparative Perspective (Brill, 2015).

Of or relating to ancient lower Mesopotamia and its empire centered in Babylon.

Archaeological site in modern-day Iraq where the remains of a ziggurat lie.

1Kgs 21

Naboth's Vineyard
1Later the following events took place: Naboth the Jezreelite had a vineyard in Jezreel, beside the palace of King Ahab of Samaria.2And Ahab s ... View more

1Kgs 21:9-10

9She wrote in the letters, “Proclaim a fast, and seat Naboth at the head of the assembly;10seat two scoundrels opposite him, and have them bring a charge agains ... View more

1Kgs 21:13

13The two scoundrels came in and sat opposite him; and the scoundrels brought a charge against Naboth, in the presence of the people, saying, “Naboth cursed God ... View more

Deut 21:18-21

Rebellious Children
18If someone has a stubborn and rebellious son who will not obey his father and mother, who does not heed them when they discipline him,19th ... View more

Deut 22:13-21

Laws concerning Sexual Relations
13Suppose a man marries a woman, but after going in to her, he dislikes her14and makes up charges against her, slandering her b ... View more

Num 35:24

24then the congregation shall judge between the slayer and the avenger of blood, in accordance with these ordinances;

Deut 17:5-7

5then you shall bring out to your gates that man or that woman who has committed this crime and you shall stone the man or woman to death.6On the evidence of tw ... View more

Num 35:30

30If anyone kills another, the murderer shall be put to death on the evidence of witnesses; but no one shall be put to death on the testimony of a single witnes ... View more

Deut 17:6-7

6On the evidence of two or three witnesses the death sentence shall be executed; a person must not be put to death on the evidence of only one witness.7The hand ... View more

1Kgs 21:10

10seat two scoundrels opposite him, and have them bring a charge against him, saying, ‘You have cursed God and the king.’ Then take him out, and stone him to de ... View more

1Kgs 21:13

13The two scoundrels came in and sat opposite him; and the scoundrels brought a charge against Naboth, in the presence of the people, saying, “Naboth cursed God ... View more

Lev 24:10­-16

* Invalid citation format *

1Sam 22:9-19

9Doeg the Edomite, who was in charge of Saul's servants, answered, “I saw the son of Jesse coming to Nob, to Ahimelech son of Ahitub;10he inquired of the Lord f ... View more

Deut 19:19

19then you shall do to the false witness just as the false witness had meant to do to the other. So you shall purge the evil from your midst.

 NEH Logo
Bible Odyssey has been made possible in part by the National Endowment for the Humanities: Exploring the human endeavor
Any views, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this website, do not necessarily represent those of the National Endowment for the Humanities.